Northside St. Thomas Restaurants: Where to Eat from Sunrise to Sunset
- STT Mag
- 2 hours ago
- 3 min read
The Northside of St. Thomas is a feast for the senses...lush tropical landscapes, salty ocean breezes, and a dining scene as vibrant as the views. From sunrise coffee to sunset cocktails, this side of the island offers something for every craving. Here’s what to check out if you happen to staying Northside or just want to explore the quieter side of the St. Thomas a little bit.
Breakfast Bliss: Northside Grind
Mornings on the Northside start best at Northside Grind. This cozy café is a local favorite, serving breakfast, lunch, coffee, and drinks from 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. Grab a steaming latte, a hearty breakfast wrap, and soak in the laid-back island vibes before your day’s adventures.
Late Morning by the Beach: Magens Bay Beach Café
After breakfast, head to Magens Bay Beach Café for beachfront bliss. Open from 9:30 a.m. to 5 p.m., it’s the perfect stop for a late breakfast, light lunch, or an ice-cold drink while enjoying one of the most iconic beaches in the Caribbean. With that turquoise water just steps away, you might find it hard to leave.
Lunch with a View: The Shack at Hull Bay
Tucked away in a relaxed beach setting, The Shack at Hull Bay serves fresh lunch and dinner options perfect for a casual mid-day meal. Whether you opt for a local seafood dish or a classic burger, the salty air and ocean backdrop make everything taste better.
A Local Love: Brook’s Bar
If you want to taste the real St. Thomas, Brook’s Bar is where you go. This no-frills, all-heart spot isn’t about polished menus or fancy plating; it’s about authentic Caribbean comfort food and the kind of warmth that makes you feel like you’ve been coming here for years. The crowd here is a mix of friends catching up over lunch and visitors lucky enough to have been pointed in the right direction. Conversations flow easily, music hums in the background, and there’s an unspoken agreement that no one’s in a rush. Oh and also beware the Mamajuana...a local Caribbean drink....you gotta have at least one but any more than that and you'll be walking home! ;P
Dinner in the Hills: Old Stone Farmhouse
For a romantic date night or special celebration, Old Stone Farmhouse delivers rustic charm and refined dining. Nestled in the island, this historic restaurant pairs candlelit ambiance with creative dishes that highlight fresh, local ingredients.
Sunset Finale: Fish Bar
Cap off your Northside dining journey with a visit to Fish Bar. Perched high above the island, it offers sweeping ocean views, fresh-caught seafood, and inventive craft cocktails. Time your reservation for golden hour and watch the sky transform as you savor your final bite of the day.
Pro Tip: The Northside is especially magical in the late afternoon...whether you’re dining mountainside or beachside, sunset here is an experience you won’t forget.
From casual beach shacks to elegant dining rooms, Northside St. Thomas restaurants serve up flavors as unforgettable as the scenery. No matter where you choose to eat, you’ll leave with a happy heart, a full belly, and a deep appreciation for this special slice of island life.
Hungry for more? This is just a taste of the island’s incredible food scene. Subscribe to St. Thomas Magazine and you’ll never miss our latest dining guides, local favorites, and insider tips for making the most of your next island getaway.