Island Hideaways: Unique Places to Stay in St. Thomas

If you're dreaming of a weekend by the sea or an island escape with style, here are three places that offer personality, charm, and top-notch experiences; each with its own island vibe. Whether you want all-inclusive ease, a romantic upscale resort, or a taste of history, these standout properties deliver.

Bolongo Bay Beach Resort – The Only All-Inclusive on the Island

Bolongo Bay is a family-owned gem and the only true all-inclusive resort on St. Thomas. Set on a beautiful stretch of sand with swaying palms and beachfront rooms, this laid-back resort includes three meals daily, unlimited house drinks, and access to snorkel gear, paddle-boards, Hobie Cats, and kayaks...all included in your stay. And they do an super fun, "Rum Snorkel Hunt" every Wednesday with their guests!

Food & Drink Highlights: Enjoy coastal comfort food and Caribbean favorites at The Oasis Restaurant: a friendly restaurant with live music, beach parties, and signature cocktails like the "Iggie's Painkiller" and conch fritters, fresh-caught fish, and rotating dinner specials. Speaking of the beloved, Iggies, construction is under way and we hope to see it open again very soon! Follow their FB group, Friends of Bolongo Bay Resort to keep up with progress!

Extras & Activities:

• Book a catamaran sail or turtle snorkel trip directly from the resort.

• Chill at the swim-up pool bar or unwind in a beachfront hammock.

• Ideal for: families, couples, or groups seeking convenience and fun right on site.

• Kayaks, paddle-boards, snorkel gear and hobie cats are available for guests to use during their stay

On site fun and activities at Bolongo Bay Beach Resort

Buoy Haus at Frenchman's Reef: Stylish Oceanfront Resort for Sea Lovers

Buoy Haus is an oceanfront boutique resort at Frenchman's Reef offering modern luxury with laid-back island vibes. Located right on Morningstar Beach, this resort is all about sun, sea, and elevated relaxation.

Gorgeous morning sunrise at Buoy Haus @Frenchman's Reef, St. Thomas

Food & Drink Highlights: Start your day with breakfast at Salt Shack, serving smoothie bowls, island-style breakfast sandwiches, and espresso drinks. Sip creative cocktails and small bites at SandBar, perfect for golden hour lounging.

For dinner, indulge in fresh seafood and Caribbean flavors at Isla Blue, the resort's upscale dinner spot with ocean views.

Extras & Amenities:

• Oceanfront infinity pool, luxury cabanas, and beachside service.

• Access to water sports, snorkeling, and beach games.

• Spa services, fitness center, and curated island experiences.

Nearby Attractions:

• Quick drive to downtown Charlotte Amalie for shopping and dining.

• Close to Skyride to Paradise Point, Havensight Mall, and local marinas.

• Ideal for: couples, honeymooners, and travelers looking for a chic, sea-focused stay.

Hotel 1829: A Historic St. Thomas Favorite

Hotel 1829 is a timeless charmer located in a lovingly preserved 19th-century mansion in Charlotte Amalie. Featuring exposed stone walls, arched windows, and antique touches, this boutique hotel brings old-world elegance to your island stay.

Hotel 1829: a historic favorite in the heart of downtown Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas.

Food & Drink Highlights: Dine at The Restaurant at 1829, offering elevated Caribbean-inspired cuisine with a focus on fresh, local ingredients. Sunday Brunch offered from 10am-2pm and Bar Bites at The Rumporium from Thursday-Saturday

Extras & Nearby Attractions:

• Lounge in the rooftop courtyard with harbor views.

• Explore downtown shops, historic landmarks, and the bustling Emancipation Garden.

• Ideal for: history buffs, explorers, and guests who want charm with convenience.

Which One Fits You Best?

Bolongo Bay

All-inclusive, beachy, family

Vacationers wanting everything included

All meals, drinks, water sports, catamaran sails

Buoy Haus

Stylish, oceanfront, upscale

Couples & travelers seeking a luxe beach vibe

Infinity pool, beach bar, dining options, close to town

Hotel 1829

Historic, downtown, stylish

Culture-loving travelers & solo guests

Historic mansion, rooftop lounge, on-site dining & bar

View from the the island looking down over Buoy Haus @Frenchaman's Reef.

Booking Tips for these Unique Island Stays

• Bolongo Bay: Ask about seasonal specials or package deals for longer stays. Great for travelers who

  want one price, all-in.

• Buoy Haus: Book early for oceanfront rooms; check for packages including spa services or dining credits.

• Hotel 1829: Book early during festival season or cruise peaks to snag this central, charming location.

For more great recs on places to stay, eat, and explore, subscribe to St. Thomas Magazine for insider tips, local favorites, and curated island itineraries.

Subscribe